Iain3
Big Member
you make the assumption everyone can get rid of their tanks, not everyone can.
If you have the option of clipping a tank off or sending it up the line, then great, but if you don't, you need to carry the swing weight or dump the tank.
You should have planned the dive and tested the kit on shallow dives before you do anything significant so if you are having bouyancy problems it is because you made a mistake or lost some lead on the dive, either way it should be a very rare event.
In this scenario if you have a lot of deco to do let the cylinder go to the surface, if you lose it you lose it, better than risking losing your life. As someone said earlier, take the regs off, adds a bit of weight to you and cuts your losses.