Double Fatality in June 2014 (UK) - Inquest and Media Reports

Both divers should have survived . Unfortunately diver "A" didn't validate his cells with a Dil Flush.
And diver "B" lost his onboard dil and turned the wrong gas off. Both have pressure gauges! .
If one of the other divers had assisted instead of watching/filming he may very well have survived.
I know this is a personal decision but sometimes all it takes is a helping hand to prevent a disaster
I am a firm believer that as your diving progresses , and the risks .So should your awareness and
rescue skills. Just my two pence worth.
 
Actually I think you'll find it was the 50's and he referenced that work as well.:read:

Cheers
Larry

No i think you will find I'm right with my dates . old hard divers using re breathers know all about co2 and oxygen tox long be4 ww2 so I'd stick with my dates

Best
 
Last edited:
No i think you will find I'm right with my dates . old hard divers using re breathers know all about co2 and oxygen tox long be4 ww2 so I'd stick with my dates

Best

You are most probably right in respect of the hard hat divers. Simon quoted and displayed some scientific studies of CO2 and its relationship to OxTox from the 50's. Either way I understand a little better physiologically what happens to blood flow in the brain with higher CO2 and therefore the increased susceptibility to OxTox. Not something I will now forget in a hurry.

Regards
Larry


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk HD
 
My point is simple.

The diver did not die because of old cells he died because he didnt check or monitor his cells

Cells either calibrate or they dont

WHen i had my three cell failure dive my brand spankig new cells refused to calibrate in my Hammer head

Martin parker blamed it on my Hammer Head and said my Classic head would calibrate OK

It did calibrate just fine and all three cells failed on the first dive.

Old or new calibration is no test of cell health and infact it can and does cover up cell failures.

Thats why I NEVER calibrate my unit unlless after a PP02 in air and PP02 in 02 passive test has been done. If my cells are significantly out from my last dive I will want to know why.

Cells are very stable till they start to fail.

Generaly if i do 50 dives in a year I may have to recalibrate 2 maybe 3 times in that year

I see divers calibrate at home recalibarte on the boat and recalibrate imediatly before kitting up and I wonder what cell failure they are trying to cover up?


Calibration is where the unit sees a cell is not reading corectly and re jigs the compensation to get that cell back in range. Thats prety much all it is. The cell not tested under stress and whilst calibration will reject cells that fall outside X Y milivolt range its is blatently obvious that it will let through cells that cant perform during dive conditions.

ATB

Mark

Doesn't calibration also adjust for atmospheric pressure on the day and at the location of the dive ?

JJ training says to calibrate each dive day if not before each dive, or at least it did when I was trained.
 
I'm with Mark on this one, I rarely calibrate. if the cells all uniformly read .21 ish in air and 98% plus on a surface O2 flush, and I can spike them to @ 1.6 in the water when I want to, then I'm a happy bunny. without constantly calibrating I really notice if one starts to drift.

However if someone can come up with a good reason why I should calibrate every day I'm willing to listen.
 
Doesn't calibration also adjust for atmospheric pressure on the day and at the location of the dive ?

JJ training says to calibrate each dive day if not before each dive, or at least it did when I was trained.

My TDI MOD 1 training said i should swap out all three cells at once and if i got asuspected C02 hit i shoud take a sanity breath??????

That was bollocks as well :D

ATB

Mark
 
Doesn't calibration also adjust for atmospheric pressure on the day and at the location of the dive ?

JJ training says to calibrate each dive day if not before each dive, or at least it did when I was trained.
AP gave me the same advise with same reasoning when I had my cell issues. Never believed in this bullshit, they just sold crap for a while ...
 
I replace my cells whenever they either reach 18 months from date of manufacture or 12 months after package was opened, whichever date happens first. Cells are fuel supplied, and have an extremely sharp drop off when they run out of fuel. The other part of my acceptable risk is to dive with BOV attached to offboard, use a dragger mouthpiece with strap, but I also have a SP S600 on offboard and practice by flipping BOV as a DSV and switching to S600 to stay current.

As far as calibration: I don't calibrate daily. I'll calibrate at the beginning of the week at a new location, otherwise I Validate them daily before each dive. I maintain a lot of online process analyzer in a Hydrocarbons cracker plant, and we seldom calibrate, but we Validate all the time. Plot charting would show if your cells are working properly and would show if they are drifting down or up. Going between slightly above the line and slightly below each time you check them is acceptable.
 
I'm with Mark on this one, I rarely calibrate. if the cells all uniformly read .21 ish in air and 98% plus on a surface O2 flush, and I can spike them to @ 1.6 in the water when I want to, then I'm a happy bunny. without constantly calibrating I really notice if one starts to drift.

However if someone can come up with a good reason why I should calibrate every day I'm willing to listen.

What do you do if you notice one has drifted slightly ?

Nothing ?

Calibrate ?

Be "extra careful" ?
 
What do you do if you notice one has drifted slightly ?

Nothing ?

Calibrate ?

Be "extra careful" ?



First thing I do is check the cell conections & biox them (and the cell its self) then ill swap the cell arround to see if the error folowed the cell. If It does i and the drop is significant (like .99 .99 .80) Ill probably bin the cell and fit a new one (especialy as its fit date is the oldest of the three)

If its within .1 having confirmed the cell contacts are good and done the wire wiggle test only then I'll recalibrate and ensure the cell is in the middle and as you say id be extra cautious on the dive. (more o2 spikes than normal possably another mid dive dill flush cell confirmation)

ATB

Mark
 
What do you do if you notice one has drifted slightly ?

Nothing ?

Calibrate ?

Be "extra careful" ?

I run 4 cells with cell 1,2,3 on the controller and HUD and 2,3,4 on the backup handset . I'd check the cell contacts are clean and flash it up. if still off and the drifting cell is 1,2 or 3 I'd move the 'suspect cell' to cell 4, and put my cell 4 'spare in it's place (which I know is good because I've been looking at it for many dives) then recalibrate it and watch cell 4. if it still carried on drifting over subsequent dives I'd bin it as it's not stable.
 
Im of a similar mindset. I only calibrate when i need to.

Im sure the obvious doesnt need stating, but doing it this way you can see the cells starting to age. If you just calibrate every time, you wont know anything is going wrong until the cal fails, at which point its to late.... and you're probably fully kitted and raring to go ;)

Truth be told, the main way i know a cell is close to failling is watching their response on a dive. you can see when one cell starts reacting more slowly.
 
If you just calibrate every time, you wont know anything is going wrong until the cal fails, at which point its to late.... and you're probably fully kitted and raring to go ;)

I don't agree. Is the assumption that everyone who calibrates each dive/day (i.e. as instructed for us Inspiration divers) simply don't take any additional steps/care in their cell verification procedure?

That's not what I do at least!

Matt.
 
Guess I'm a bit lost.

So you guys would actually get in the water with a 4yo, 3yo, and 18month old cells in a 3 cell unit? Assuming they read 0.21 in ambient and hit 0.98+ with an O2 flush?
 
no. that's not what was being discussed. what we were discussing was whether or not you need to calibrate your cells every time you switch the unit on and whether doing so masks any gradual reduction in cell performance making that degradation in cell performance harder to spot.

personally I run cells for between 12 and 18 months then bin them.
 
Im of a similar mindset. I only calibrate when i need to..

Ditto... I'd imagine some divers confuse checking calibration with actually calibrating?
My Shearwater powered MCCR was only calibrated twice last year but I confirmed the calibration prior to every dive.
 
Back
Top